Casey's Pizza vs Jimmy John's (2026)

Side-by-side comparison of menu prices, calories, and value. 94 items at Casey's Pizza vs 42 items at Jimmy John's.

Quick answer: As of May 2026, Casey's Pizza averages $5.63 per item across 94 menu items, while Jimmy John's averages $8.55 across 42 items. Casey's Pizza is $2.93 cheaper per item (34% difference). Casey's Pizza has lower average calories (370 vs 996 per item).

Quick Comparison

Casey's Pizza vs Jimmy John's: Quick Price & Menu Comparison
Metric	Casey's Pizza	Jimmy John's	Winner
Avg Price	$5.63	$8.55	Casey's Pizza
Menu Items	94	42	Casey's Pizza
Avg Calories	370	996	Casey's Pizza
US Locations	2,900	2,550	Casey's Pizza
Secret Menu	0	1	Jimmy John's

Casey's Pizza is 34% cheaper on average than Jimmy John's ($2.93 less per item).

Cheapest Items

Casey's Pizza

Caramel Chocolate Pecan Cookie $0.89

Sugar Cookie $0.89

Chocolate Chunk Cookie $0.89

Macadamia Nut Cookie $0.89

Bavarian Long John $0.89

Jimmy John's

Pickle $0.89

Real Potato Chips $1.39

Jumbo Kosher Dill Pickle $1.39

Soft Drink $1.49

Dasani® Water $1.49

Lowest Calorie Options

Casey's Pizza

Buffalo Wings 55 cal

Turkey & Cheese 103 cal

Ham & Cheese 105 cal

Italian 113 cal

Hash Brown 140 cal

Jimmy John's

Jimmy Chips 140 cal

Cookie 410 cal

Chocolate Chunk Cookie 410 cal

Chocolate Chunk Cookie Tray 410 cal

#4 Turkey Tom 510 cal

Deep Comparison: Casey's Pizza vs Jimmy John's

Calorie Value (cents per calorie)

Casey's Pizza delivers 2.26¢/cal on average, while Jimmy John's delivers 1.52¢/cal. Jimmy John's gives more calories per dollar — a key metric for value-per-meal seekers.

Menu Category Overlap

Casey's Pizza and Jimmy John's share 0 menu categories (0% Jaccard overlap). Low overlap — these chains serve mostly different food categories.

What Fits in Your Budget

$10 budget: Casey's Pizza fits 0 items, Jimmy John's fits 0 items
$15 budget: Casey's Pizza fits 0 items, Jimmy John's fits 0 items
$20 budget: Casey's Pizza fits 3 items (623 cal), Jimmy John's fits 3 items (820 cal)

Where They Rank in Our 414-Chain Dataset

Casey's Pizza ranks #120 of 338 on price (cheaper than 65% of tracked chains). Jimmy John's ranks #214 of 338 (pricier than 63% of chains).

Calorie Distribution (items under 500 cal)

At Casey's Pizza, 80% of menu items with calorie data come in under 500 calories. At Jimmy John's, 20% are under 500 calories. Casey's Pizza offers more lower-calorie options proportionally.

Bottom Line

Budget pick: Casey's Pizza ($5.63 avg vs $8.55)
More variety: Casey's Pizza (94 items)
More locations: Casey's Pizza (2,900 US locations)
Best calorie value: Jimmy John's (1.52¢/cal)

Full Menus

Casey's Pizza Menu Jimmy John's Menu Cheapest Fast Food Low Calorie Guide