Casey's Pizza vs Papa John's (2026)

Side-by-side comparison of menu prices, calories, and value. 94 items at Casey's Pizza vs 79 items at Papa John's.

Quick answer: As of May 2026, Casey's Pizza averages $5.63 per item across 94 menu items, while Papa John's averages $11.72 across 79 items. Casey's Pizza is $6.09 cheaper per item (52% difference). Papa John's has lower average calories (369 vs 370 per item).

Quick Comparison

Casey's Pizza vs Papa John's: Quick Price & Menu Comparison
Metric	Casey's Pizza	Papa John's	Winner
Avg Price	$5.63	$11.72	Casey's Pizza
Menu Items	94	79	Casey's Pizza
Avg Calories	370	369	Papa John's
US Locations	2,900	3,200	Papa John's
Secret Menu	0	1	Papa John's

Casey's Pizza is 52% cheaper on average than Papa John's ($6.09 less per item).

Cheapest Items

Casey's Pizza

Caramel Chocolate Pecan Cookie $0.89

Sugar Cookie $0.89

Chocolate Chunk Cookie $0.89

Macadamia Nut Cookie $0.89

Bavarian Long John $0.89

Papa John's

Cheese (Large) $0.50

Special Garlic $0.50

Barbeque $0.50

Blue Cheese $0.50

Buffalo $0.50

Lowest Calorie Options

Casey's Pizza

Buffalo Wings 55 cal

Turkey & Cheese 103 cal

Ham & Cheese 105 cal

Italian 113 cal

Hash Brown 140 cal

Papa John's

Jalapeño Peppers 60 cal

Ranch 100 cal

Special Garlic 150 cal

Honey Mustard 150 cal

Blue Cheese 160 cal

Deep Comparison: Casey's Pizza vs Papa John's

Calorie Value (cents per calorie)

Casey's Pizza delivers 2.26¢/cal on average, while Papa John's delivers 3.50¢/cal. Casey's Pizza gives more calories per dollar — a key metric for value-per-meal seekers.

Menu Category Overlap

Casey's Pizza and Papa John's share 0 menu categories (0% Jaccard overlap). Low overlap — these chains serve mostly different food categories.

What Fits in Your Budget

$10 budget: Casey's Pizza fits 0 items, Papa John's fits 0 items
$15 budget: Casey's Pizza fits 0 items, Papa John's fits 1 item (270 cal)
$20 budget: Casey's Pizza fits 3 items (623 cal), Papa John's fits 3 items

Where They Rank in Our 414-Chain Dataset

Casey's Pizza ranks #120 of 338 on price (cheaper than 65% of tracked chains). Papa John's ranks #279 of 338 (pricier than 82% of chains).

Calorie Distribution (items under 500 cal)

At Casey's Pizza, 80% of menu items with calorie data come in under 500 calories. At Papa John's, 93% are under 500 calories. Papa John's offers more lower-calorie options proportionally.

Bottom Line

Budget pick: Casey's Pizza ($5.63 avg vs $11.72)
More variety: Casey's Pizza (94 items)
More locations: Papa John's (3,200 US locations)
Best calorie value: Casey's Pizza (2.26¢/cal)

Full Menus

Casey's Pizza Menu Papa John's Menu Cheapest Fast Food Low Calorie Guide