All Restaurant Menus

Andy's Frozen Custard Menu — Starts at $1.69 for the Bottled Water

· Sourced from official menu data

Items
74
From
$1.69
Avg
$5.52
Monitored
May 2026
Cheapest: Bottled Water $1.69 Biggest section: Concretes (21 items)
170 US Locations Find a location near you →

Andy's Frozen Custard is a Missouri-based American chain known for fresh, made-every-hour frozen custard concretes and sundaes.

The Andy's Frozen Custard menu has 74 items with prices ranging from $1.69 to $9.99. The average menu item costs $5.52. The cheapest item is the Bottled Water at $1.69. Andy's Frozen Custard has 8 menu categories and 170 locations across the United States.

About Andy's Frozen Custard

Founded 1986

Andy's Frozen Custard is the largest frozen custard-only chain in the United States, with more than 190 company-owned and franchised stores across 15 states.

Order Andy's Frozen Custard Delivery
Get it delivered to your door
DoorDashUber EatsGrubhub

How Andy's Frozen Custard Prices Compare

vs All 414 Chains
46% cheaper
$5.52 avg vs $10.16
vs 290 Desserts Chains
32% cheaper
$5.52 avg vs $8.14

Andy's Frozen Custard is cheaper than 66% of the 414 restaurant chains we track. With an average item price of $5.52, it's one of the more affordable options.

What Your Budget Gets You at Andy's Frozen Custard

$10 Budget
  • Andry’s Frozen Custard Bar (Small)$9.99
Total: $9.99
$0.01 left over
$15 Budget
  • Malts (Small)$4.79
  • Malts (Large)$4.79
  • Shakes (Small)$4.79
Total: $14.37
$0.63 left over

Andy's Frozen Custard Rankings

#97
Cheapest Desserts Chain
out of 290 desserts chains
#114
Most Affordable Overall
out of 338 chains tracked
#150
Most Menu Items
74 items
#141
Most US Locations
170 locations
Data accuracy: Menu prices are US national averages collected from official restaurant websites. Prices may vary by location. Found an error? Let us know.

Hungry? Order Andy's Frozen Custard Now

Skip the line and get Andy's Frozen Custard delivered to your door.

Order on DoorDash Order on Uber Eats

Similar to Andy's Frozen Custard

Pieology
$5.54 avg — similar prices
16 items · 100 locations
Bill Millers BBQ
$5.55 avg — 1% pricier
102 items · 80 locations
Bush's Chicken
$5.49 avg — 1% cheaper
20 items · 70 locations
Corner Bakery
$5.55 avg — 1% pricier
85 items · 90 locations
Hot Head Burritos
$5.49 avg — 1% cheaper
51 items · 75 locations

Helpful Guides

Cheapest Fast Food Low Calorie Meals Secret Menu Guide Cheapest by Category Prices by Country