Potbelly Menu: 70 Items from $1.00 to $9.70

Prices monitored May 2026 · Sourced from official menu data

Items

From

$1.00

Avg

$4.23

Monitored

May 2026

Cheapest: Pickle $1.00 Biggest section: Sandwiches (16 items)

445 US Locations Find a location near you →

Potbelly Sandwich Shop is a Chicago-based American fast-casual chain known for toasty warm sandwiches, hand-dipped shakes, and live music.

The Potbelly menu has 70 items with prices ranging from $1.00 to $9.70. The average menu item costs $4.23. The cheapest item is the Pickle at $1.00 (2 calories). Potbelly has 9 menu categories and 445 locations across the United States.

About Potbelly

Founded 1977

Potbelly Sandwich Shop, also known as Potbelly Sandwich Works, is an American fast-casual restaurant chain with over 400 locations that focuses on submarine sandwiches and milkshakes. It is owned by RaceTrac.

Source: Wikipedia · CC BY-SA 4.0

Order Potbelly Delivery

Get it delivered to your door

DoorDash Uber Eats Grubhub

Potbelly Sandwiches

Clubby

$6.35

1009 cal
Italian

$5.30

1115 cal
Turkey Breast

$5.10

767 cal
Smoked Ham

$5.10

849 cal
Grilled Chicken Mediterranean

$6.50

667 cal
Tuna Salad

$5.10

740 cal
Pizza Sandwich

$5.30

945 cal
A Wreck

$5.30

921 cal
Grilled Chicken

$5.70

45 cal
Roast Beef

$5.10

875 cal
Mediterranean

$5.50

667 cal
Chicken Salad

$5.10

874 cal
Meatball

$5.10

947 cal
Vegetarian

$5.10

933 cal
PB & J

$5.00

1525 cal
Sicilian

$6.35

848 cal

How Potbelly Prices Compare

vs All 414 Chains

58% cheaper

$4.23 avg vs $10.16

vs 289 Chicken Chains

50% cheaper

$4.23 avg vs $8.45

Potbelly is cheaper than 86% of the 414 restaurant chains we track. With an average item price of $4.23, it's one of the more affordable options.

What Your Budget Gets You at Potbelly

$5 Budget

PB & J$5.00

Total: $5.001525 cal

$0.00 left over

$15 Budget

Italian$5.30
Pizza Sandwich$5.30
Bag Mini Cookies$3.95

Total: $14.552252 cal

$0.45 left over

Potbelly Rankings

#34

Cheapest Chicken Chain

out of 289 chicken chains

#49

Most Affordable Overall

out of 338 chains tracked

#162

Most Menu Items

70 items

#87

Most US Locations

445 locations

Data accuracy: Menu prices are US national averages collected from official restaurant websites. Prices may vary by location. Found an error? Let us know.